TY - JOUR

T1 - Studying the potential of rock magnetism to distinguish combustion structures of different type

AU - Kostadinova-Avramova, Maria

AU - Dimitrov, Petar

AU - Kosterov, Andrei

AU - Surovitskii, Leonid

N1 - Publisher Copyright: © 2022

PY - 2022/8/1

Y1 - 2022/8/1

N2 - Rock magnetism has a significant potential to elucidate archaeological issues related to firing process owing to the strong dependence of clay magnetic properties on firing conditions. The present study is an attempt to characterize some basic fuel installations (hearths, household ovens, pottery kilns, kilns for building ceramics and metallurgical ovens) by the most common magnetic parameters (magnetic remanence, initial magnetic susceptibility, Koenigsberger ratio, frequency-dependent magnetic susceptibility and viscosity coefficient), accumulating a set of relevant magnetic data for exemplary structures. Rasmussen method was used for firing temperature determinations. It is concluded that household ovens, used for cooking/heating activities only, were fired at temperatures below 500 °C. The acquired thermoremanence is in most cases partial TRM, generally less than 800 mA/m, the measured magnetic susceptibility does not exceed 300× 10−8m3/kg, and the corresponding Q ratios are mostly below 10. Experimentally baked clays show that already a firing at temperatures slightly above 500 °C yield much stronger and more stable TRM, and higher χ and Q ratio. Hearth and pottery kilns appear indistinguishable at this research stage, but systematically higher Q ratios were observed for the pottery kilns. Rising the temperature in the kilns for building ceramics and metallurgical ovens causes formation of a higher proportion of coarse-grained hematite and epsilon iron oxide, resulting in thermoremanence increase and magnetic susceptibility decrease. Firing temperatures determined for the household ovens corroborate well the observed magnetic parameters indicating a maximum operating temperature of not more than 460–470 °C. On the other hand, they appear to be underestimated when the highest firing intensity was expected (at T > 900 °C). This is indicative that further studies in this aspect are needed. The slags studied fail to produce any feasible result in terms of their firing temperatures, probably because of their strong inhomogeneity and/or complicated firing history. There is an excellent agreement between the estimated temperatures for clays baked in an experimental dual chamber kiln and the thermocouple readings. Differences in firing atmosphere between archaeological structures (or their experimental analogues) and laboratory furnaces probably have the least effect on low-temperature heated objects (i.e., household ovens) and the strongest on high-temperature ones where reducing conditions dominate that should be taken into account in the data interpretation. An overestimation of Tfiring can happen for low-temperature materials due to possible intense magnetic transformations above 600 °C.

AB - Rock magnetism has a significant potential to elucidate archaeological issues related to firing process owing to the strong dependence of clay magnetic properties on firing conditions. The present study is an attempt to characterize some basic fuel installations (hearths, household ovens, pottery kilns, kilns for building ceramics and metallurgical ovens) by the most common magnetic parameters (magnetic remanence, initial magnetic susceptibility, Koenigsberger ratio, frequency-dependent magnetic susceptibility and viscosity coefficient), accumulating a set of relevant magnetic data for exemplary structures. Rasmussen method was used for firing temperature determinations. It is concluded that household ovens, used for cooking/heating activities only, were fired at temperatures below 500 °C. The acquired thermoremanence is in most cases partial TRM, generally less than 800 mA/m, the measured magnetic susceptibility does not exceed 300× 10−8m3/kg, and the corresponding Q ratios are mostly below 10. Experimentally baked clays show that already a firing at temperatures slightly above 500 °C yield much stronger and more stable TRM, and higher χ and Q ratio. Hearth and pottery kilns appear indistinguishable at this research stage, but systematically higher Q ratios were observed for the pottery kilns. Rising the temperature in the kilns for building ceramics and metallurgical ovens causes formation of a higher proportion of coarse-grained hematite and epsilon iron oxide, resulting in thermoremanence increase and magnetic susceptibility decrease. Firing temperatures determined for the household ovens corroborate well the observed magnetic parameters indicating a maximum operating temperature of not more than 460–470 °C. On the other hand, they appear to be underestimated when the highest firing intensity was expected (at T > 900 °C). This is indicative that further studies in this aspect are needed. The slags studied fail to produce any feasible result in terms of their firing temperatures, probably because of their strong inhomogeneity and/or complicated firing history. There is an excellent agreement between the estimated temperatures for clays baked in an experimental dual chamber kiln and the thermocouple readings. Differences in firing atmosphere between archaeological structures (or their experimental analogues) and laboratory furnaces probably have the least effect on low-temperature heated objects (i.e., household ovens) and the strongest on high-temperature ones where reducing conditions dominate that should be taken into account in the data interpretation. An overestimation of Tfiring can happen for low-temperature materials due to possible intense magnetic transformations above 600 °C.

KW - Ancient combustion structures

KW - Baked clay

KW - Firing temperatures

KW - Magnetic properties

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85132852330&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1016/j.jas.2022.105639

DO - 10.1016/j.jas.2022.105639

M3 - Article

AN - SCOPUS:85132852330

VL - 144

JO - Journal of Archaeological Science

JF - Journal of Archaeological Science

SN - 0305-4403

M1 - 105639

ER -