V.I. Lamansky vs N.G. Chernyshevsky: From the history of forgotten polemics

Результат исследований: Научные публикации в периодических изданияхстатья

Выдержка

The article analyses the relations between Nikolay Chernyshevsky (1818-1889) and Vladimir Lamansky (1833-1914), who were students of professor N.N. Sreznevsky (1812-1880) of St. Petersburg University. The author observes that their mutual aversion was not only determined by their personal antipathy, but was also based on different worldviews and philosophical values (Westernism of Chernyshevsky and Slavophilism of Lamansky). The essential attention is paid to their polemics provoked by the publication of Chernyshevsky's article "National tactlessness" in Sovremennik in 1861. The article was an overview of the early issues of Slovo - a newspaper published in Lvov - which evoked Lamansky's reaction in a Slavophile newspaper Den'. The author notes that a special question about the language of the Galician Rusins put by Chernyshevsky gave Lamansky grounds for proposing his version of the origins of Russian literary language and for upholding Rusins' historical and cultural right to use Russian literary language instead of Ukrainian. The Slavophiles (I.S. Aksakov, V.I. Lamansky and P.A. Lavrovsky) accused Chernyshevsky of denying Rusins the right to use the Russian literary language, thus provoking the split in Russian ethnos and expressing the Polish viewpoint. In respond, Chernyshevsky pointed out that there were rather class then ethnic contradictions in Austria-Hungary. He also blamed Galician Rusins for political immaturity and refused to refer them to the Western line of the Russian nation, denying them of any national identity. The author concludes that the further polemics of the language led Lamansky to the civilization conception of "three worlds" with language as a main geopolitical force.

Язык оригиналаанглийский
Страницы (с-по)41-59
Число страниц19
ЖурналRusin
Том52
Номер выпуска2
DOI
СостояниеОпубликовано - 1 янв 2018

Отпечаток

history
language
newspaper
Austria-Hungary
accused
worldview
civilization
national identity
History
Pannonian Rusyns
university teacher
Language
Literary Language
Values
student
Conception
World View
Aversion
Civilization
Ethnos

Предметные области Scopus

  • Языки и лингвистика
  • Антропология
  • История
  • Социология и политические науки
  • Языки и лингвистика
  • Литературоведение и теория литературы

Цитировать

@article{bb8f96fcc2b044929d57e5409073210f,
title = "V.I. Lamansky vs N.G. Chernyshevsky: From the history of forgotten polemics",
abstract = "The article analyses the relations between Nikolay Chernyshevsky (1818-1889) and Vladimir Lamansky (1833-1914), who were students of professor N.N. Sreznevsky (1812-1880) of St. Petersburg University. The author observes that their mutual aversion was not only determined by their personal antipathy, but was also based on different worldviews and philosophical values (Westernism of Chernyshevsky and Slavophilism of Lamansky). The essential attention is paid to their polemics provoked by the publication of Chernyshevsky's article {"}National tactlessness{"} in Sovremennik in 1861. The article was an overview of the early issues of Slovo - a newspaper published in Lvov - which evoked Lamansky's reaction in a Slavophile newspaper Den'. The author notes that a special question about the language of the Galician Rusins put by Chernyshevsky gave Lamansky grounds for proposing his version of the origins of Russian literary language and for upholding Rusins' historical and cultural right to use Russian literary language instead of Ukrainian. The Slavophiles (I.S. Aksakov, V.I. Lamansky and P.A. Lavrovsky) accused Chernyshevsky of denying Rusins the right to use the Russian literary language, thus provoking the split in Russian ethnos and expressing the Polish viewpoint. In respond, Chernyshevsky pointed out that there were rather class then ethnic contradictions in Austria-Hungary. He also blamed Galician Rusins for political immaturity and refused to refer them to the Western line of the Russian nation, denying them of any national identity. The author concludes that the further polemics of the language led Lamansky to the civilization conception of {"}three worlds{"} with language as a main geopolitical force.",
keywords = "Assimilation, Chernyshevsky, Culture, Ethnic independence, Historiosophy, Lamansky, Literary language, Nation, Rusins, Slavophiles",
author = "Malinov, {A. V.}",
year = "2018",
month = "1",
day = "1",
doi = "10.17223/18572685/52/4",
language = "English",
volume = "52",
pages = "41--59",
journal = "РУСИН",
issn = "1857-2685",
publisher = "Общественная ассоциация {"}Русь{"}",
number = "2",

}

V.I. Lamansky vs N.G. Chernyshevsky : From the history of forgotten polemics. / Malinov, A. V.

В: Rusin, Том 52, № 2, 01.01.2018, стр. 41-59.

Результат исследований: Научные публикации в периодических изданияхстатья

TY - JOUR

T1 - V.I. Lamansky vs N.G. Chernyshevsky

T2 - From the history of forgotten polemics

AU - Malinov, A. V.

PY - 2018/1/1

Y1 - 2018/1/1

N2 - The article analyses the relations between Nikolay Chernyshevsky (1818-1889) and Vladimir Lamansky (1833-1914), who were students of professor N.N. Sreznevsky (1812-1880) of St. Petersburg University. The author observes that their mutual aversion was not only determined by their personal antipathy, but was also based on different worldviews and philosophical values (Westernism of Chernyshevsky and Slavophilism of Lamansky). The essential attention is paid to their polemics provoked by the publication of Chernyshevsky's article "National tactlessness" in Sovremennik in 1861. The article was an overview of the early issues of Slovo - a newspaper published in Lvov - which evoked Lamansky's reaction in a Slavophile newspaper Den'. The author notes that a special question about the language of the Galician Rusins put by Chernyshevsky gave Lamansky grounds for proposing his version of the origins of Russian literary language and for upholding Rusins' historical and cultural right to use Russian literary language instead of Ukrainian. The Slavophiles (I.S. Aksakov, V.I. Lamansky and P.A. Lavrovsky) accused Chernyshevsky of denying Rusins the right to use the Russian literary language, thus provoking the split in Russian ethnos and expressing the Polish viewpoint. In respond, Chernyshevsky pointed out that there were rather class then ethnic contradictions in Austria-Hungary. He also blamed Galician Rusins for political immaturity and refused to refer them to the Western line of the Russian nation, denying them of any national identity. The author concludes that the further polemics of the language led Lamansky to the civilization conception of "three worlds" with language as a main geopolitical force.

AB - The article analyses the relations between Nikolay Chernyshevsky (1818-1889) and Vladimir Lamansky (1833-1914), who were students of professor N.N. Sreznevsky (1812-1880) of St. Petersburg University. The author observes that their mutual aversion was not only determined by their personal antipathy, but was also based on different worldviews and philosophical values (Westernism of Chernyshevsky and Slavophilism of Lamansky). The essential attention is paid to their polemics provoked by the publication of Chernyshevsky's article "National tactlessness" in Sovremennik in 1861. The article was an overview of the early issues of Slovo - a newspaper published in Lvov - which evoked Lamansky's reaction in a Slavophile newspaper Den'. The author notes that a special question about the language of the Galician Rusins put by Chernyshevsky gave Lamansky grounds for proposing his version of the origins of Russian literary language and for upholding Rusins' historical and cultural right to use Russian literary language instead of Ukrainian. The Slavophiles (I.S. Aksakov, V.I. Lamansky and P.A. Lavrovsky) accused Chernyshevsky of denying Rusins the right to use the Russian literary language, thus provoking the split in Russian ethnos and expressing the Polish viewpoint. In respond, Chernyshevsky pointed out that there were rather class then ethnic contradictions in Austria-Hungary. He also blamed Galician Rusins for political immaturity and refused to refer them to the Western line of the Russian nation, denying them of any national identity. The author concludes that the further polemics of the language led Lamansky to the civilization conception of "three worlds" with language as a main geopolitical force.

KW - Assimilation

KW - Chernyshevsky

KW - Culture

KW - Ethnic independence

KW - Historiosophy

KW - Lamansky

KW - Literary language

KW - Nation

KW - Rusins

KW - Slavophiles

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85052137843&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.17223/18572685/52/4

DO - 10.17223/18572685/52/4

M3 - Article

AN - SCOPUS:85052137843

VL - 52

SP - 41

EP - 59

JO - РУСИН

JF - РУСИН

SN - 1857-2685

IS - 2

ER -