The Boundaries of Context: Contextual Knowledge in Research on Networked Discussions

Результат исследований: Публикации в книгах, отчётах, сборниках, трудах конференцийстатья в сборнике материалов конференциинаучнаярецензирование

Аннотация

Today’s studies of networked discussions may be divided into theory-driven and data-driven, but both lines of research neglect the role of contextual knowledge in assessment of real-world public discourse. As scholars note, without context, data lose meaning and value; however, there is a striking vacuum of scholarly discussion on how to delineate the relevant context for network discussion studies, as well as what procedures of its description in academic publications should be employed. As a mediator between theories and data-driven results, context has a potential of eliminating the opposition between theory- and data-driven research designs. In an attempt to conceptualize context, we suggest to adapt the long-term experience of cognitive linguistics and critical discourse analysis for developing rigorous procedures of selection, assessment, and explicit description of relevant context(s). We bring attention to the paradox that, in online discussion studies, scholars extract sociologically relevant conclusions from the data of non-sociological nature (that is, either text or network structures), and argue it might be fruitful for selection of appropriate contextual background. After meta-reviewing the conceptual papers on online discussion research and using our own experience in such studies of over 7 years, we suggest three types of contexts for network discussions: cognitive, platform-technological, and media/communicative contexts – that need to be taken into account in network discussion studies.

Язык оригиналаанглийский
Название основной публикацииNetworks in the Global World V - Proceedings of NetGloW 2020
РедакторыArtem Antonyuk, Nikita Basov
ИздательSpringer Nature
Страницы165-179
Число страниц15
ISBN (печатное издание)9783030648763
DOI
СостояниеОпубликовано - 2021
Событие5th Networks in the Global World Conference, NetGloW 2020 - St. Petersburg, Российская Федерация
Продолжительность: 7 июл 20209 июл 2020

Серия публикаций

НазваниеLecture Notes in Networks and Systems
Том181
ISSN (печатное издание)2367-3370
ISSN (электронное издание)2367-3389

конференция

конференция5th Networks in the Global World Conference, NetGloW 2020
СтранаРоссийская Федерация
ГородSt. Petersburg
Период7/07/209/07/20

Предметные области Scopus

  • Системотехника
  • Обработка сигналов
  • Компьютерные сети и коммуникации

Fingerprint Подробные сведения о темах исследования «The Boundaries of Context: Contextual Knowledge in Research on Networked Discussions». Вместе они формируют уникальный семантический отпечаток (fingerprint).

Цитировать