Order without Law: A review of the Russian edition of Robert Ellickson's book

Результат исследований: Научные публикации в периодических изданияхОбзорная статья

Выдержка

Gaidar Institute Publishing House has published the Russian translation of the book by the famous American Professor Robert Ellickson. The book describes the phenomenon of stable social order forming independently of legal system. Ellickson is not only interested in the mere fact of the formation and stability of informal norms, but also in the existence of non-legal approach to dispute settlement, including disputes related to legal rights violation. In his book, Robert Ellickson brings together theoretical assumptions and methods used in two important schools or traditions in the study of the interaction of law and social phenomena that emerged in the United States, namely in the "Law and Society" movement and in the "Law and Economics" movement. The practical basis of the research was a detailed study by the author of the dispute resolution practices among farmers in Shasta County located in the U.S. state of California. Based on the solid theoretical foundation as well as on the results of field research, the author concludes that the order based on law and enforced by state institutions, and the order formed without law and the state exist simultaneously, complementing each other. Ellickson offers his own theoretical interpretation of social control and its elements, based on who exercises control, who monitors the adherence to or violation of rules, and who rewards or punishes it. Firmly grounded both theoretically and empirically the findings of Ellickson's study are an important and helpful reminder about objective limits of effective government intervention in society and economy and about limited role of law in human life.

Язык оригиналаанглийский
Страницы (с-по)250-256
Число страниц7
ЖурналEkonomicheskaya Politika
Том12
Номер выпуска1
DOI
СостояниеОпубликовано - 1 янв 2017

Отпечаток

edition
Law
publishing house
social order
social control
legal system
field research
reward
farmer
university teacher
interpretation
economy
interaction
school
economics
Violations
Society

Предметные области Scopus

  • Экономика и эконометрия
  • Финансы
  • Социология и политические науки

Цитировать

@article{3ffe2c8f26764e319b30075812071c42,
title = "Order without Law: A review of the Russian edition of Robert Ellickson's book",
abstract = "Gaidar Institute Publishing House has published the Russian translation of the book by the famous American Professor Robert Ellickson. The book describes the phenomenon of stable social order forming independently of legal system. Ellickson is not only interested in the mere fact of the formation and stability of informal norms, but also in the existence of non-legal approach to dispute settlement, including disputes related to legal rights violation. In his book, Robert Ellickson brings together theoretical assumptions and methods used in two important schools or traditions in the study of the interaction of law and social phenomena that emerged in the United States, namely in the {"}Law and Society{"} movement and in the {"}Law and Economics{"} movement. The practical basis of the research was a detailed study by the author of the dispute resolution practices among farmers in Shasta County located in the U.S. state of California. Based on the solid theoretical foundation as well as on the results of field research, the author concludes that the order based on law and enforced by state institutions, and the order formed without law and the state exist simultaneously, complementing each other. Ellickson offers his own theoretical interpretation of social control and its elements, based on who exercises control, who monitors the adherence to or violation of rules, and who rewards or punishes it. Firmly grounded both theoretically and empirically the findings of Ellickson's study are an important and helpful reminder about objective limits of effective government intervention in society and economy and about limited role of law in human life.",
keywords = "Economics, Informal norms, Law, Social order",
author = "Kadochnikov, {Denis V.}",
year = "2017",
month = "1",
day = "1",
doi = "10.18288/1994-5124-2017-1-10",
language = "English",
volume = "12",
pages = "250--256",
journal = "Ekonomicheskaya Politika",
issn = "1994-5124",
publisher = "Редакция журнала Экономическая политика",
number = "1",

}

Order without Law : A review of the Russian edition of Robert Ellickson's book. / Kadochnikov, Denis V.

В: Ekonomicheskaya Politika, Том 12, № 1, 01.01.2017, стр. 250-256.

Результат исследований: Научные публикации в периодических изданияхОбзорная статья

TY - JOUR

T1 - Order without Law

T2 - A review of the Russian edition of Robert Ellickson's book

AU - Kadochnikov, Denis V.

PY - 2017/1/1

Y1 - 2017/1/1

N2 - Gaidar Institute Publishing House has published the Russian translation of the book by the famous American Professor Robert Ellickson. The book describes the phenomenon of stable social order forming independently of legal system. Ellickson is not only interested in the mere fact of the formation and stability of informal norms, but also in the existence of non-legal approach to dispute settlement, including disputes related to legal rights violation. In his book, Robert Ellickson brings together theoretical assumptions and methods used in two important schools or traditions in the study of the interaction of law and social phenomena that emerged in the United States, namely in the "Law and Society" movement and in the "Law and Economics" movement. The practical basis of the research was a detailed study by the author of the dispute resolution practices among farmers in Shasta County located in the U.S. state of California. Based on the solid theoretical foundation as well as on the results of field research, the author concludes that the order based on law and enforced by state institutions, and the order formed without law and the state exist simultaneously, complementing each other. Ellickson offers his own theoretical interpretation of social control and its elements, based on who exercises control, who monitors the adherence to or violation of rules, and who rewards or punishes it. Firmly grounded both theoretically and empirically the findings of Ellickson's study are an important and helpful reminder about objective limits of effective government intervention in society and economy and about limited role of law in human life.

AB - Gaidar Institute Publishing House has published the Russian translation of the book by the famous American Professor Robert Ellickson. The book describes the phenomenon of stable social order forming independently of legal system. Ellickson is not only interested in the mere fact of the formation and stability of informal norms, but also in the existence of non-legal approach to dispute settlement, including disputes related to legal rights violation. In his book, Robert Ellickson brings together theoretical assumptions and methods used in two important schools or traditions in the study of the interaction of law and social phenomena that emerged in the United States, namely in the "Law and Society" movement and in the "Law and Economics" movement. The practical basis of the research was a detailed study by the author of the dispute resolution practices among farmers in Shasta County located in the U.S. state of California. Based on the solid theoretical foundation as well as on the results of field research, the author concludes that the order based on law and enforced by state institutions, and the order formed without law and the state exist simultaneously, complementing each other. Ellickson offers his own theoretical interpretation of social control and its elements, based on who exercises control, who monitors the adherence to or violation of rules, and who rewards or punishes it. Firmly grounded both theoretically and empirically the findings of Ellickson's study are an important and helpful reminder about objective limits of effective government intervention in society and economy and about limited role of law in human life.

KW - Economics

KW - Informal norms

KW - Law

KW - Social order

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85026458205&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.18288/1994-5124-2017-1-10

DO - 10.18288/1994-5124-2017-1-10

M3 - Review article

AN - SCOPUS:85026458205

VL - 12

SP - 250

EP - 256

JO - Ekonomicheskaya Politika

JF - Ekonomicheskaya Politika

SN - 1994-5124

IS - 1

ER -