Выдержка
| Язык оригинала | английский |
|---|---|
| Журнал | ВЕСТНИК ТОМСКОГО ГОСУДАРСТВЕННОГО УНИВЕРСИТЕТА. ФИЛОСОФИЯ. СОЦИОЛОГИЯ. ПОЛИТОЛОГИЯ |
| Номер выпуска | 48 |
| Состояние | Опубликовано - 2019 |
Ключевые слова
- truth
- legal argumentation
- adversary and investigative process models
- judicial mistake
- The Karamazov Brothers
Предметные области Scopus
- Философия
- Право
Цитировать
}
Kirillova N. P., Lisanyuk E. N. Truth and legal argumentation in Fyodor Dostoevsky’s The Karamazov Brothers. / Кириллова, Наталия Павловна; Лисанюк, Елена Николаевна.
В: ВЕСТНИК ТОМСКОГО ГОСУДАРСТВЕННОГО УНИВЕРСИТЕТА. ФИЛОСОФИЯ. СОЦИОЛОГИЯ. ПОЛИТОЛОГИЯ, № 48, 2019.Результат исследований: Научные публикации в периодических изданиях › статья › научная › рецензирование
TY - JOUR
T1 - Kirillova N. P., Lisanyuk E. N. Truth and legal argumentation in Fyodor Dostoevsky’s The Karamazov Brothers
AU - Кириллова, Наталия Павловна
AU - Лисанюк, Елена Николаевна
PY - 2019
Y1 - 2019
N2 - We examine the reasons of the judicial mistake in the Dmitry Karamazov case depicted by F. Dostoevsky in The Karamazov Brothers and argue that the truth can and should be established in both of the process types, the adversary and the investigative, and that the three conceptions of truth, referential, inferential and pragmatic, play an evaluative role in that. The Dmitry Karamazov case shows that the formal view of the truth suffices for deciding a case, but it cannot prevent the judicial mistakes, when the epistemological ideal of the material truth falls into oblivion.
AB - We examine the reasons of the judicial mistake in the Dmitry Karamazov case depicted by F. Dostoevsky in The Karamazov Brothers and argue that the truth can and should be established in both of the process types, the adversary and the investigative, and that the three conceptions of truth, referential, inferential and pragmatic, play an evaluative role in that. The Dmitry Karamazov case shows that the formal view of the truth suffices for deciding a case, but it cannot prevent the judicial mistakes, when the epistemological ideal of the material truth falls into oblivion.
KW - truth
KW - legal argumentation
KW - adversary and investigative process models
KW - judicial mistake
KW - The Karamazov Brothers
M3 - Article
JO - ВЕСТНИК ТОМСКОГО ГОСУДАРСТВЕННОГО УНИВЕРСИТЕТА. ФИЛОСОФИЯ. СОЦИОЛОГИЯ. ПОЛИТОЛОГИЯ
JF - ВЕСТНИК ТОМСКОГО ГОСУДАРСТВЕННОГО УНИВЕРСИТЕТА. ФИЛОСОФИЯ. СОЦИОЛОГИЯ. ПОЛИТОЛОГИЯ
SN - 1998-863X
IS - 48
ER -