Comments to the article Tsanko V. Tsankov and Uwe Czarnetzki "Information hidden in the velocity distribution of ions and the exact kinetic Bohm criterion

Николай Александрович Тимофеев; Владимир Сергеевич Сухомлинов; Александр Мустафаев

Comments to the article Tsanko V. Tsankov and Uwe Czarnetzki "Information hidden in the velocity distribution of ions and the exact kinetic Bohm criterion

Переведенное название: Комментарий к статье Цанко В. Цанко и Уве Чарнецки "Информация, скрытая в распределении ионов по скоростям и точный кинетический критерий Бома"

Николай Александрович Тимофеев, Владимир Сергеевич Сухомлинов, Александр Мустафаев

Кафедра оптики

Результат исследований: Научные публикации в периодических изданиях › статья

Аннотация

The Comment is devoted to some mathematical inaccuracies made by the authors of the paper "Information hidden in the velocity distribution of ions and the exact kinetic Bohm criterion", PSST, 2011". In the Comment we show that the diapason of plasma parameters for the validity of the theoretical results obtained by the authors was defined incorrectly; we made more accurate definition of this diapason. As a result we show that it is impossible to confirm or refute the feasibility of the Bohm kinetic criterion on the base of the data of the cited paper.

Переведенное название	Комментарий к статье Цанко В. Цанко и Уве Чарнецки "Информация, скрытая в распределении ионов по скоростям и точный кинетический критерий Бома"
Язык оригинала	английский
Номер статьи	PSST-102012
Страницы (с-по)	038001-6
Число страниц	7
Журнал	Plasma Sources Science and Technology
Том	27
Номер выпуска	3
Состояние	Опубликовано - 16 фев 2018

Предметные области Scopus

Физика и астрономия (все)

Ключевые слова

ион, распределение по скоростям, критерий Бома

Цитировать

Тимофеев, Николай Александрович ; Сухомлинов, Владимир Сергеевич ; Мустафаев, Александр. / Comments to the article Tsanko V. Tsankov and Uwe Czarnetzki "Information hidden in the velocity distribution of ions and the exact kinetic Bohm criterion. В: Plasma Sources Science and Technology. 2018 ; Том 27, № 3. стр. 038001-6.

@article{77cb03a82a5d429080fff7ac8c15e6d3,

title = "Comments to the article Tsanko V. Tsankov and Uwe Czarnetzki {"}Information hidden in the velocity distribution of ions and the exact kinetic Bohm criterion",

abstract = "The Comment is devoted to some mathematical inaccuracies made by the authors of the paper {"}Information hidden in the velocity distribution of ions and the exact kinetic Bohm criterion{"}, PSST, 2011{"}. In the Comment we show that the diapason of plasma parameters for the validity of the theoretical results obtained by the authors was defined incorrectly; we made more accurate definition of this diapason. As a result we show that it is impossible to confirm or refute the feasibility of the Bohm kinetic criterion on the base of the data of the cited paper. ",

keywords = "ион, распределение по скоростям, критерий Бома",

author = "Тимофеев, {Николай Александрович} and Сухомлинов, {Владимир Сергеевич} and Александр Мустафаев",

year = "2018",

month = feb,

day = "16",

language = "English",

volume = "27",

pages = "038001--6",

journal = "Plasma Sources Science and Technology",

issn = "0963-0252",

publisher = "IOP Publishing Ltd.",

number = "3",

}

Comments to the article Tsanko V. Tsankov and Uwe Czarnetzki "Information hidden in the velocity distribution of ions and the exact kinetic Bohm criterion. / Тимофеев, Николай Александрович ; Сухомлинов, Владимир Сергеевич; Мустафаев, Александр.

В: Plasma Sources Science and Technology, Том 27, № 3, PSST-102012, 16.02.2018, стр. 038001-6.

Результат исследований: Научные публикации в периодических изданиях › статья

TY - JOUR

T1 - Comments to the article Tsanko V. Tsankov and Uwe Czarnetzki "Information hidden in the velocity distribution of ions and the exact kinetic Bohm criterion

AU - Тимофеев, Николай Александрович

AU - Сухомлинов, Владимир Сергеевич

AU - Мустафаев, Александр

PY - 2018/2/16

Y1 - 2018/2/16

N2 - The Comment is devoted to some mathematical inaccuracies made by the authors of the paper "Information hidden in the velocity distribution of ions and the exact kinetic Bohm criterion", PSST, 2011". In the Comment we show that the diapason of plasma parameters for the validity of the theoretical results obtained by the authors was defined incorrectly; we made more accurate definition of this diapason. As a result we show that it is impossible to confirm or refute the feasibility of the Bohm kinetic criterion on the base of the data of the cited paper.

AB - The Comment is devoted to some mathematical inaccuracies made by the authors of the paper "Information hidden in the velocity distribution of ions and the exact kinetic Bohm criterion", PSST, 2011". In the Comment we show that the diapason of plasma parameters for the validity of the theoretical results obtained by the authors was defined incorrectly; we made more accurate definition of this diapason. As a result we show that it is impossible to confirm or refute the feasibility of the Bohm kinetic criterion on the base of the data of the cited paper.

KW - ион, распределение по скоростям, критерий Бома

M3 - Article

VL - 27

SP - 38001

EP - 38006

JO - Plasma Sources Science and Technology

JF - Plasma Sources Science and Technology

SN - 0963-0252

IS - 3

M1 - PSST-102012

ER -